The 7 Brew CMO said it directly: the third place between home and work is your car. This is a confession dressed as a positioning statement. The third place was Ray Oldenburg's concept, built around lingering and strangers and the particular social texture of a room you did not own but were welcome to inhabit. The drive-thru eliminates every one of those conditions. There is no room. There is no lingering. The transaction happens through glass.
Starbucks imported the Oldenburg idea to American retail in the 1990s and built a company around it. Comfortable chairs. Long tables. The implicit permission to stay. The concept worked well enough that it became shorthand for a category of experience, and then the shorthand got detached from the experience, and then the experience got value-engineered out of the stores, and now Starbucks is remodeling to get back to something it used to do instinctively.
The term survived the concept, which is the more interesting thing. Brands can now claim the third-place designation for almost any context where a transaction occurs, because the original meaning has been fully dissolved into marketing language. The drive-thru is a third place. The app is a third place. The car is a third place. The word has been so thoroughly annexed that the experience it was supposed to describe has no name anymore.
What gets lost is harder to specify. Serendipitous conversation with a stranger is not easily quantified. Neither is the experience of sitting in a public room with no purchase obligation hanging over you. These things existed in some Starbucks stores in some cities in some years, imperfectly and inconsistently, and they mattered more than the coffee. The coffee was the ticket. The room was the product. Selling the ticket without the room is a different business, and it is the business most of these chains are actually running while using language that implies otherwise.
The remodel Starbucks is now executing is an acknowledgment that the language without the experience eventually costs you the customer who wanted the experience. The drive-thru cohort and the lingering cohort are not the same customer. They were never the same customer.


